All Posts Why Tracking Law Firm Marketing ROI Is Important

Many firms invest thousands of dollars into marketing spend, whether that be through digital marketing efforts or more traditional efforts. Still, a majority of those firms have no idea what their marketing dollars are generating for them in terms of new revenue for the firm. That is where ROI, or return on investment, comes into play.

Why Tracking ROI Is Essential For Law Firm Marketers and Firm Leaders

Calculating and keeping track of marketing return on Investment is a critical metric that all law firms should be tracking for a variety of reasons some of which include the following:

  • Understanding What Marketing Campaigns Are Driving Revenue – By closely tracking ROI and keeping tabs on the performance of your marketing campaigns, you’ll be able to have a clear understanding of what marketing campaigns are driving revenue for your firm. Once you can understand which marketing campaigns are driving the most qualified leads and actually converting into revenue for the firm, you can face the next steps.
  • Make Data-Driven Decisions – Once you understand what marketing campaigns are working most effectively, you can use that information to make data-driven marketing decisions that will make the best use of your marketing dollars.
  • Better Allocate Marketing Spend – Once you’ve acquired all of the data for your marketing campaigns, you can better allocate your marketing spend. For example, if you noticed that your SEO efforts showed a 5x return for your Elder Law practice, you may consider putting additional budget towards further bolstering that practice area or even begin investing in another. On the other hand, if you notice the social media advertising you were investing in was not generating the revenue you initially thought, you would now know to make an educated decision on how to best allocate that spend whether it be to lower it or put that budget toward higher-performing marketing campaigns.

Top Three Challenges Law Firms Face When Tracking ROI

ROI is a metric all law firms hope to track but often struggle to do so. Let’s dive into the top challenges that we’ve noticed law firms face when trying to track ROI on their marketing spend.

Inaccurate Tracking

The first and most frequent challenge we’ve seen is having inaccurate or no tracking in place. The best free tool to use for tracking your leads is Google Analytics (GA4). If you don’t have an analytics property set up for your law firm that would be a great first step. Next, you want to determine what it is you want to track – Phone calls? Contact Form submissions? Chatbot interactions? The world is your oyster. It is best to identify the main conversion actions you feel are most likely to indicate a new potential client. Some of the most common ones we see and encourage all of our clients to track include contact forms and phone calls.

Long Sales Cycles

Long sales cycles can pose a difficulty for many law firms when it comes to tracking ROI. That is because someone may fill out a contact form by finding the website in January but then may not retain an attorney until June. For example, this is prevalent with firms that concentrate on Family Law, more specifically Divorce. This can make the tracking process difficult to keep a good grip on and takes close tracking of each lead to properly determine ROI.

Difficulties With Attribution

Attribution can be hard to determine, especially if you are investing in multi-channel marketing. Even if you have accurate tracking set up, this can still be complicated to nail down. This is why we often recommend our clients use a call tracking software such as CallRail, especially if they are investing in SEO, Paid Ads, and any other channels. A call tracking software can provide additional in-depth insights that Google Analytics may not be able to provide to you, such as what landing page a specific caller called from and what traffic channel they came to your website from.

Overcoming ROI Tracking Issues With ROO

Tracking ROI on marketing campaigns can sometimes be difficult to accurately measure, given how nebulous some aspects of digital marketing can be. This is why ROO, or return on objective, is a great alternative if you are unable to closely track the metrics needed for ROI. This type of tracking allows your firm to prove the impact of specific marketing campaigns when it is not possible or feasible to tie them directly to revenue. With ROO tracking, you can still see the impact of your marketing campaigns and make data-driven decisions; you just don’t have to have all of the nitty-gritty details to do so.

Looking to Get Your Law Firms Tracking Organized?

If you are looking to get your law firm’s tracking organized and under control you’ve come to the right blog article. At 9Sail, we work with our clients to ensure proper tracking is in place and work together to help determine the impact of their marketing efforts in terms of new potential clients and increasing profit. If you are looking for an SEO partner that is invested in the success of your firm then contact us today to get a conversation started.

Helpful resources

Webinar Recap – 2025 State of the Industry

   In 2025, the legal industry found itself at…

Read More
What Is a Conversion in PPC? A Law Firm Guide to Tracking What Really Matters

Every law firm judges the success of their PPC campaign…

Read More
AI Search Optimization for IP Law Firms: Why Traditional SEO Won’t Be Enough in 2026

If your intellectual property firm isn’t optimized for modern AI…

Read More
5 SEO Tips for More Organic Traffic

Organic traffic refers to the people who find and visit…

Read More
Is Your Slow Website Costing You AI-Generated Client Referrals?

Picture this: It’s Tuesday afternoon, and somewhere in your city,…

Read More
Top Five Key Website Optimization Strategies for Your Law Firm

With hundreds of thousands of law firms in the United…

Read More
How to Plan and Create SEO-Optimized Content

Producing content for your law firm’s website is helpful in…

Read More
Multi-Practice Law Firm Digital Strategy: Avoiding the ‘Jack of All Trades’ Trap

Multi-practice firms are hemorrhaging high-value opportunities to specialty boutiques every…

Read More
Conversion Tracking and Optimization Checklist for Law Firms

Most firms invest in marketing without knowing what’s actually working. This checklist shows you how to track every lead, call, and consultation back to its source—so you can see which campaigns drive clients and which just drain budget.

Read More
Webinar Recap – Conversion Tracking for Optimized Spend

 Setting the Stage: Why Conversion Tracking Matters The core…

Read More

Discover the power of effective digital marketing.

Sign up to receive 9Sail’s exclusive content and tactical tips, focused on helping law firms grow.

9Sail takes your privacy seriously and will only use your personal information to deliver communications you have requested of us. You can change your preferences at any time.