All Posts Why Google Business Profile Optimization Matters

Google Business Profiles

There are many resources out there on how to optimize your Google Business Profile (formerly “Google My Business”) but few advise on why to do so. Why go through the steps?

If your business serves a local area, Google plays a huge role in how customers find you, especially for companies with a physical office location where business is conducted (e.g. law firm offices, retail stores, medical offices).

If you’ve ever searched for a service or even a particular product, odds are you have encountered that block of three local businesses at the very top of the search engine results page (SERP). This is the ‘Local Pack’ and besides paid advertisements, it’s the very first thing a potential customer sees in their search result. The local pack is even more prominent on mobile devices, which make up a larger percentage of online traffic year-over-year. This placement at the top of the SERP, and attaining it, is a key factor that can draw in new customers to your business.

Claim & Verify

Odds are that this step has probably already been done by you, someone at your company or a third-party marketer you may be working with. It’s still important to go over as it’s a critical step. Claiming and verifying your Google Business Profile does two things: (1) it tells Google your company is engaged and cares about its online presence and (2) it allows you to make edits on the fly as needed (like if business hours change). Having hands-on, verified access ensures you have full control over what is put out there on your business’s profile. This is also incredibly important when it comes to responding to reviews. We’ll touch on that shortly.

If There’s An Empty Space, Fill It Out

When assessing the different data fields available to you in the Google Business Profile dashboard, have the mindset of “If Google thinks these aspects are important for potential customers, they probably are.” Google’s local search algorithm is a bit different from the traditional algorithm that dictates everything else you find below the Local Pack and ads on Page 1 of any search. The local algorithm takes a lot of factors into account – and what you fill out is a key part of that. Certain fields such as “Primary Category”, “Additional Categories” and “Services” can make or break landing the coveted top three businesses in specific searches (or if you end up just outside of it). It also helps you focus on the customers you’re targeting. Here’s an example: If you manage a broad family law firm but divorce cases are specifically driving the most business and revenue out of all the different sub-practices under the family law umbrella, set your primary category as “Divorce Lawyer” and keep “Family Law Attorney” under “Additional Categories.” Measures like this will help you match specific search intent for those who already know exactly what they want.

Other Items To Keep In Mind

Your business description is also a very important field many skip over when populating data into their profile. Be meticulous with your contact information. Google allows various ways for people to contact you: links to your main website as well as designating a specific link to set up an appointment. The fields can vary depending on your business’s industry, so keep that in mind as well. Ensure the right links are in the right spots so inbound lead traffic is accounted for exactly as you intended.

Reviews

Reviews play a large factor in the local algorithm as well. Depending on what businesses are in proximity to the individual searching, the local pack displayed in the search results will show companies with more favorable scores. Some may have lower scores than the other two but they may have a much higher overall quantity of reviewers who contributed to that score. In the aggregate, the volume of reviews and overall average score help get your company to the very top of the local pack. Also, if you see competitors with a perfect 5/5 review score, don’t let that intimidate you. It’s been widely argued in studies that the average consumer often finds a perfect score to be a bit questionable, while another business with a 4.8 or 4.7 with more total reviews seemed like a better choice.

Going back to the importance of claiming and verifying – a verified business owner (or manager) has the capability of responding to reviews. This is incredibly important. Here’s a direct quote from Google on the matter:

When you reply to reviews, it shows that you value your customers and their feedback. High-quality, positive reviews from your customers can improve your business visibility and increase the likelihood that a shopper will visit your location.

I personally consider responding to reviews another spoke in the wheel of “optimization” because it serves as an added signal to Google that you’re an engaged business entity that is hands-on with their online presence. Furthermore, responding to negative reviews, and doing so in a timely fashion, will speak volumes. It can sometimes be intimidating to craft a good response to a negative review, but the thing to keep in mind as you write it is this: write it so it addresses the individual who left the review but the bigger picture is that this response will be seen by any future potential customers. A calm and reasonable response will outweigh an outlier’s negative review depending on the context of the situation. Potential customers will see that you addressed the negative feedback right away and did so in a professional manner. This measure paints a much better picture than having a negative review hang out there unanswered for months (or, sometimes, years).

Always Evolving

The Google Business Profile is a fluid product that’s always changing. New business categories show up in the available preset options every few months as Google sees the need for them. Google had to implement new data fields at the beginning of COVID-19 so businesses across every industry (especially places like restaurants and retail) could pivot and show what steps were being taken to ensure the safety of their staff as well as their clients.

Like many others in SEO, I’m disheartened when one states they are a Google Business Profile “expert.” You can’t be an expert in something that is always changing. Be knowledgeable, aware, and have the flexibility to adjust as needed. Those aspects are vital in the online marketing world as a whole. And if you can’t figure something out, just Google it.

Need Guidance Setting Up and Managing Your Google Business Profile?

The 9Sail team is here to support you along the way. Feel free to contact us to see how we can help you today!

Helpful resources

Webinar Recap – The 2027 Legal Rankings Season Has Already Started. Is Your Firm Ready?

A recap of 9Sail’s webinar on building a legal rankings strategy that supports business development, strengthens digital visibility, and creates long-term competitive advantage.

Read More
Watch This Before You Plan a 2027 Law Firm Website Redesign

A 60-minute webinar for law firm marketing leaders on protecting brand equity and domain authority through mergers, nailing positioning, and building a CMS that lasts.

Read More
How to Structure Legal Alerts for AI Search Visibility: Critical Steps for Big Law

The Architecture Problem (Not the Volume Problem) Most large law…

Read More
How Sheppard Navigated a Full Digital Transformation Without Losing Ground in Search

For law firms, a website isn’t just a marketing tool;…

Read More
Specific is Terrific: How to Differentiate Your Law Firm Practice Pages for AI Search Visibility

The Vagueness Trap: Why Broad Practice Descriptions Work Against You…

Read More
7 Digital PR Campaign Types That Actually Build Authority for Law Firms

The Prestige PR Problem There’s a version of this conversation…

Read More
12 Digital PR KPIs Big Law Marketing Leaders Must Track in 2026

Here’s something most digital PR agencies won’t tell you upfront:…

Read More
The Law Firm CMO’s Guide to Evaluating GEO and AEO Agencies in 2026

If you are a law firm CMO or marketing director…

Read More
Webinar Recap – The Brand Moat Broke. Takeaways From 9Sail’s 2026 Digital Visibility Index

A recap of the 2026 Digital Visibility Index webinar exploring what the data may be revealing about the future of law firm visibility.

Read More
9 Brand-Mention Tactics That Earn Big Law AI Citations , Ranked by Impact

To Earn Big Law AI Citations real estate, Am Law…

Read More

Discover the power of effective digital marketing.

Sign up to receive 9Sail’s exclusive content and tactical tips, focused on helping law firms grow.

9Sail takes your privacy seriously and will only use your personal information to deliver communications you have requested of us. You can change your preferences at any time.